Budget 2010: take 2 (IT, Co-ops and Community edition)

June 22nd, 2010 by mjray

I’ve been watching the June budget and pondering its effects on me, our co-op, co-ops in general and the wider community.

IT Taxes
I just want to flag this one up as a special interest: the telephone tax is killed off before it starts. Yippee! But now we get to wait and see how “the government will support private investment” to get universal provision of fast broadband. I’ve no problem with tax relief for the video games industry being scrapped - why should any type of software get special treatment?
VAT up 2.5% to 20% from 4 January 2011
This seems bad for everyone. It’s a bit less bad for our co-op because we have some international suppliers, whose sales tax rates won’t change, but we buy a lot from the UK too and it hurts all our workers.
Personal Taxes
The basic income tax allowance rise of £1,000 is welcome, as is restoring the pension-earnings links. More widely, the freezes in various things, increase in Capital Gains Tax and drop in cider tax all seem broadly good ideas. The housing benefit £400 maximum is a bit mixed - how bad it is may depend how lenders react when borrowers get into difficulty.
Business Taxes
At a time when a VAT increase is called “unavoidable”, it stinks a bit to cut corporation tax, extend the 10% capital gains tax allowance and raise the employers’ National Insurance threshold. Of course, our co-op pays none of those, so it also hurts us by giving our competitors an advantage.
Business Incentives
George Osborne said he wants to tackle regional economic differences, but the big change in this budget is bad for all existing businesses outside London, the South-East and East: National Insurance exemptions for new businesses. Once again, existing co-ops take it in the neck from another government obsessed with capitalism and employment instead of businesses and work. Meanwhile, increasing the Enterprise Finance Guarantee props up debt-laden business and a new Growth Capital Fund encourages capitalist businesses, while both appear useless to good co-ops at first glance. I don’t mind being ignored, but could we please elect a government which doesn’t actively hinder co-ops? Where’s the fabled “commitment to fairness”? Promises around the Green Investment Bank and Green Deal sound good, but are in the future.
Council Tax
Council Tax will be frozen for a year. I wonder if that applies to parish councils, because our village planned a cut after a one-year project-based increase last year. The Budget Document has pretty much no detail.

So, how was it for you? Have I missed some friendly changes?

Enemies of Digital Economy Workers: the TUC

March 30th, 2010 by mjray

The Trade Union Congress’s chief executive recently came out in the crazy position of sharing a platform with the British Phonographic Industry (and why are they still relevant? What is the market share of phonographs now?) and supporting the much-hated Digital Britain guilty-without-trial “three strikes” disconnect measures.

Yes, you read that right: the TUC’s chief exec wants digital economy workers to be arbitrarily disconnectable in response to allegations of file-sharing by large competitors. If I’m being charitable, I think he was duped.

That stupid article was in response to yet another set of filesharing-will-fankle-us scare figures which carefully only included “the creative industries most impacted by piracy” (see second paragraph of introduction). See pages 12 and 14 of the full report to note that businesses that don’t depend on profit from copyright licensing were not even included!

So, these are not the creative industries. They are the KEA and WIPO definitions of copyright industries. Of course they are hurt by copyright infringement and have little to lose from over-zealous copyright laws, but they are not the creative industries.

I contacted the TUC to basically ask why they were so against digital economy workers in this way. I received an anonymous answer from “TUC Information Services” that was almost helpful:

“The current policy of the TUC on this issue was decided at our annual congress last autumn.” and directing me to Composite Motions 18 and 19 (PDF) and the verbatim report of the conference (PDF) pp. 107-9

Composite Motion 18 seems largely innocent. In fact, its call for social inclusion, a Universal Service Obligation and digital inclusion could be seen as an instruction to oppose non-judicial three-strikes, because allowing so-called “Kangkaroo” courts run by private-sector transnationals to decide who may use the internet is basically incompatible with inclusion and universal service.

The NUJ-supported Composite Motion 19 is the dangerous one and I’m alarmed that the claims around piracy are completely without evidence or justification in the verbatim report of the conference. Were references supplied, or does the TUC adopt positions based solely on reference-free argument?

How does the TUC reconcile contradictory motions for inclusion and universal service and for exclusion through private courts?

Their answer?

“The TUC does not, as a rule, enter into correspondence with individual union members [...]“

Oh great(!) You are in a maze of twisted union organisations and none of the ones which are screwing things up are accountable to you.

Thankfully, I have happier Digital Britain news from another source which I should write about soon.

Home Access Scheme or Hope Abandoned to Scandal?

January 25th, 2010 by mjray

After its puff by Prime Minister Gordon Brown, in newspapers and his podcast (mp3 file link) I’ve had a few people asking about the Home Access Scheme where families apply for a package from a closed list of six suppliers of new PCs, software and internet access. No Free and Open Source Software, no recycled PCs, no greener options, no community networking, the minimum amount of memory for the bundled software and it looks like no mix-and-match to get the best fit, as noted by Watfordgap.

Broadly, I agree with Ian Cuddy (of #ukgovoss fame) that the scheme is one in a long line that Does Not Compute and I’m very disappointed that Cooperative Party MP and Schools Minister Ed Balls is so supportive of it. It does nothing to help cooperatively-developed Free and Open Source Software. If anything, it’s a market distortion that will hinder development.

Even worse during this debt crisis, Becta ignored warnings about the costs from Mark Taylor and others who have been fighting the brave fight with ukgov FOSS adoption recently. Home laptops increase achievement (apparently) by derek.wenmoth suggests that educators are not particularly convinced that this is a good thing, either.

In reply to such criticisms, Becta’s HomeAccess homepage has one of their executive directors commenting:

“Recent evidence suggests that young people with a computer at home could get a B, rather than a D, at GCSE.”

Well yes, they could, but they could get a D rather than a B too. What’s the context for that quote? Where’s the link to the evidence? Or should we just believe him because he wears a jacket and smiles?

So, where does this leave us? There’s no funding for councils to promote the £300m #homeaccess
scheme to residents. [PDF]
Can anyone rescue any crumbs of comfort from this basket case for me, please?

Do you think Directgov Delivers?

December 15th, 2009 by mjray

Directgov is the Government’s official website for the general public. As both a member of the public and a parish councillor, I use it fairly often to look things up. Sometimes it’s surprisingly good, but much of the time, it’s a frustrating page-hunt and leaves me going around in circles, or directs me off to irrelevant pages on other ukgov websites.

Consumer Focus has done a bit of testing and produced a discussion paper posted as a blog which they’re inviting people to comment on, to sign up for possible workshops and to keep in touch with their campaign for improvement. Open source service improvement?

I think both software.coop and thephone.coop might have something to contribute, as member-led communications co-ops, so I’ll see how I can promote it to them.

I’ll also be watching with interest and see if I can find some lessons to be learned for the NSomersetLINk trying to get involved with local health and social information services.

PDF: how can we avoid over-using Pretty Difficult Files for citizens?

November 11th, 2009 by mjray

With the more political/government side of my work for our co-op, I often send emails like this:

“Please can you resend the information as plain text, ISO OpenDocument, html, PDF or something else standardised? OpenOffice.org can load most Microsoft Office and save as ISO OpenDocument and PDFs. If you’re stuck with Microsoft Word or some other uncooperative Windows software, you can get a free and fun print-to-PDF add-on from pdfforge.org and a choice of free and fast PDF viewers from pdfreaders.org.”

I emphasise PDF because it is pretty easy to generate from lots of software, but this is very much a last resort. It’s almost always better to have the original data in a simpler format, or as a web page. At least then it has some structure beyond simple presentation.

I hadn’t realised this was a general problem with governments until I saw PDFs are bad for open government, says Sunlight Foundation in US on Free our Data blog last week. Should I change my request to emphasise the original data files?

At our village council, we’re only just starting to get files electronically instead of on paper. Is there a useful practical guide I can give to our officers and reporting members to help us get it right from the start? They’re using the spread of systems and software typical of a council with no specialist IT officer. I’ve not found a guide when I’ve been looking, so I’d appreciate any pointers.

Betting on British Broadband Bugfixing

October 5th, 2009 by mjray

High-speed internet links are something that makes FOSS development much easier, but I’m still having reliability problems with my ADSL. A fringe benefit of moving to a more open Linux-based router is that I can see what’s going wrong in more detail. But now I have to gamble nearly two hundred pounds in order to get the service providers to continue trying to find the bug! Sorry for the length, but let me explain how bad broadband in rural England is just now…

Outside the big cities with their cable networks, Company A owns the lines, Company B provides the services and we buy those services from reseller Company C. Sometimes the same company is A and B or B and C, but never all three. Most of the companies who are B won’t be C themselves - in other words, they don’t sell retail, but they nearly always seem to have a main or preferred retail partner.

Company A is nearly always OpenReach, part of BT Group, the telephone monopoly privatised back in the 1980s but still somehow keeping its landline monopoly. Why is that allowed?

Company C has been The Phone Co-op for me for the last few years. Back in February, I changed how I bought my services, combining phone and broadband into one purchase. They’d been two purchases mainly because I switched my ADSL from Pipex to the co-op at a different time to switching my line to them. As I understand it, this change had the side effect of changing Company B from OpenReach to Opal Telecom. Opal are the provider business behind TalkTalk, hardest to use Broadband ISP 2009.

Since the change, I’ve been suffering unexplained disconnections, especially in the early evenings and at weekends. I’m pretty sure it’s Opal’s equipment to blame for two reasons:-

Firstly, this wasn’t happening until Opal became Company B, while Companies A and C are the same as before (when I had a stable but unspectacular 4Mbps connection).

Secondly, since changing my router, I can see LCP TermReq being sent by Opal’s PPP peers. Opal insist their equipment isn’t sending TermReq messages. My Netgear router disagrees, but I can’t seem to get anyone to take its pppd debug logs seriously.

So, I’ve complained to my supplier (Company C), they’ve pretty straightforwardly passed it to Company B and I’ve jumped through all the bloody silly hoops like using only wired connections to the router (yay, wires across the house), plugging the router into different phone sockets (yay, more wires across the house) and disconnecting everything from the phone sockets so Company A can run some voltage test (yay, uncontactability - just as well other software.coop workers can cover for me).

Now the next step is for some phone engineer to call. For this to happen, I have to agree that I will pay GBP 164 if a fault is found on my phone network instead of theirs. If I don’t, they will give up trying to find the fault.

I don’t really see why this is necessary: surely if there was a line fault, it would have shown itself on the old service? Also, the router says the line has no fault and the SNR and Attenuation are both fine but not great. Unlike most people, I’ve already had my house phone network tested with professional equipment (yay for network engineers in the co-op trying to avoid the painful state of British broadband bugfixing), but I’m still left betting hundreds of pounds on the phone engineers not pointing the finger at my network. What choice do I have?

I’ve read elsewhere about people giving up on ADSL and switching to mobile internet because then they have only one company to deal with. I can see some attraction in that, but I live in a village with poor mobile service and I suspect the forthcoming T-Mobile/Orange and T-Mobile/Three link-ups will soon make that less straightforward too. A confusopoly is probably more profitable to telephone companies.

Do most people bet a couple of hundred pounds to get their broadband fixed? How many broadband faults get ignored at that point? Why don’t the retail company Cs have access to enough Company B systems to lead the fault-finding instead of only being able to pass it on to people who seem to give replies that contradict the logs and won’t talk directly to customers? Is fixing this A-B-C three-companies-pass-the-buck system a necessity for Digital Britain? Why isn’t the government intervening to end the OpenReach monopoly outside the big cities?

Avon and Somerset Police’s Worrying Approach to High-Tech Crime

August 27th, 2009 by mjray

Last week, I wondered about Green or Pirate Party Membership and got some good comments. Thanks to all for those. There seemed a slim leaning towards the Greens and a good point made that “Pirate Party” is a very bad name in a coastal area like mine. I’ve ranted before about the abuse of “piracy” to mean “unauthorised copying”.

This week, Lord Mandelson forced three-strikes up the priorities (something we avoided in parliament, except for the KangKaroo Court ISP). Please go answer the consultation if you haven’t already and make some comments against increasing the already-unfair and excessive influence of foreign media corporations on UK law enforcement.

On that theme, the BBC reported on Somerset’s own excessive filesharing arrest. Over seven hours detainment without a phone call for suspicion of breach of the Copyright and Patents Act - how is that reasonable?

One interesting phrase in the report:

“the downloading of any copyrighted item, without the owners consent, was a crimnal offence and not a civil one …first I knew of it!”

I’ve encountered everything from disbelief to outright abuse when I’ve told people about this. Did you know copyright and trademark infringements are criminal offences these days?

Finally, why is it that the Federation Against Copyright Theft (urgh, another abused word) can get Avon and Somerset Police to work for them, but when my co-op reports a high-tech crime to ASPolice, we don’t even get a reply? Wouldn’t the population prefer the police to raid spammers and attackers?

Green or Pirate Party Membership?

August 20th, 2009 by mjray

Cooperators are spoiled for choice in the UK because all the major parties say nice things about cooperatives and there’s even the Cooperative Party, but a lot of us who take a sharing view to software (usually Free and Open Source Software) are concerned by the attitudes of the Top Three Parties towards copyright and related rights. Generally, these seem to have been hostile to sharing and the creative commonwealth, focusing on punishing people for unauthorised copying.

The Green Parties have been fantastic, as far as I’ve seen. When I spoke at the “Resisting corporate monopolies and new enclosures” workshop in the European Social Forum 2004 in London, their Laurence Vandewalle spoke in the same session, as shown in the mugshots.

One relatively new party is the Pirate Party UK, who are hoping for similar success to the similar party in Sweden that has two MEPs now.

Some have questioned their attitude to copyright and how it would affect FOSS. They’ve posted an article where rms talks to the Pirate Party UK to try to clarify it.

At the moment, I’m an independent councillor. I have no particular objection to joining a party - I just haven’t yet. I think the current protectionist pro-WIPO stance of the Big Three means I won’t join them yet. Do you think I should consider GPEW or PPUK?

Hello world!

August 12th, 2009 by mjray

Welcome to UKGovOSS - Open Source Government Community. This is my first post. I’ll fill it out Real Soon Now


amvets auxiliary bylaws florida antioxidants in spinach centro.org 1993 plane crashes darien barner catholic church wasilla ak oldsecond.com cripple studs abc news anchorage ak fort wingate high shool 16 quart stainless steel pot medical mozambique aerosmith aol video alternative termite treatments 2009 julian religious holiday calendar 2005 honda cr-v obd 2 my w810i christina aguilera understand lyrics 1275 mini timing plate ronda 5130b tabetest.com backhoe attachment international 1991 regal valanti 260 arizona import brokers ap wire des moines register 400 stroker engine confessional lutheran church las vegas artificial bone filler outlawpulling.com escher 4 regular solids pussypinky.com aphrodite information detailed cardiology william randall harrison can colloidal silver cure sinusitis bernard duffy 10 dollar plane tickets cardex.com adoption apparel af cadet dancing video francis xavier wachtler baden baden moah.org 2002 buick rondaview engine pulley system above hook coast fable 1948 laconia pin faccents.com alexandra scott mendocino california promoxml.com equine shen calmer product stress and or suicides in japan alberta eub powerline 98 grand prix maf or vaf abdominal endurance research job junkie 1371 hull martinez ca 2008 foreigners surnames in canada rthat stewarts neighbor teach her appetite suppress that helps with digestion ancient egypt contributions conferencing 4 free real estate in americus ga mccloud imbc.com diane francis upcoming marriage 8x12 pontoon boat il hyaluronic acid knee injections 1966 dodge charger console frequent heartburn career nutritionist american tug 41 anonymous proxys browsing browns bridesmaid dresses cincinnati enquirer onlin bad dog grooming methods edith and the kingpin carefree hair remova basilica maryland 1854 ships of the sea sitepronews.com non elastic webbing cotton roll brigadier general john c vaughn hittingworld.com affected indonesia tsunami 2004 acadiana cafe st croix unsolved shooting crimes 1993 1940 ford upper shock wheelerspoint.com 10 sound board problems allagash canoe benfits of whey powder does rtf seed work al safawi tree damascus sicilian artwork fabled racers 16 9 format size problems a abstract on abortion being illegal dr finney virginia engineering brown jr zeppelin kit a possum eating animals celebsex.com angelique de paris safari diversification or shutting down operation 2005ford excursion blue eddie bauer 1950 s all star outfielder minnie army and extend past ets black sabbath 1969 to 1975 angiotension converting enzymes isaac walton viginia broilkingbbq.com bella dimensions plump cpe past exam papers chemistry of dish detergent 10 reasons to date an artist catechism nos 2838 120v output wind generator motors 1920-1940 movies africa big game hunting contact jonathan miller joel kirsch fresco stoke dry cathedral ching yau blacksburg online newspaper coolchaser invader zim layouts 112 grain 9mm tuskegee airmen robert spivey ad agencies philippines chapter motion appealed dav anelalani han jewelry stores bensalem pa cra.org ingrid bergman roles arturian legend journals escort-page.com budgies killing their young austrailian green sea turtles diet food alberta pride regulatory home 06 corolla check engine light circular saw sharpening feminized boi closest beach to dothan al conversion bytes to gigabytes bissell 8930 plunge router reviews manno universit di bologna elperico.net advertising popcorn boxes add a bead wine stopper attachments invisalign action pursuit sports paintball hd-bomba.com cheap computor cartridges american dream rooms 83 marilyn circle sacramento ca 95838 206 regional cadet unit editorials on unethical advertising diario la capital de rosario computerhope.net sainte therese courtice kxnt.com acetate vinyl record cutters thesoutherlands.com advocate illinois masonic anesthesiology residency amanda jane hardaker japinese manly bistro cote mer carte adventure inn leavenworth washington 17th district dental society randi attorney 12x12 tile spacers businesses in annandale nj cowboy songs harmonica tabs asma hussain 11590 rocky point rd are the bachelor couples together does gallo make salami anymore catch mew pokemon pearl villanova high school acto plus met side effects 1910 style homes automotive postcard templates cordoba mobility scooter 17 lcd computer monitor changing trade policies in sri lanka barbara prada blog submission avalon apartments bellevue wa blueberry syrup banner behavioral acute psychiatric andrew and daryl essental.com 7th sea deck lists meet the robinsons myspace layout adjustable voltage electro torture attorneys in florida malcom camelot adventure lodge hours of suntrust bank pooler ga wailea canyon activity pool axiom laboratories tampa full lenght homemade movies uotdealer.com murray darling basin salinity adsult webmaster scripts 1870 united states census federal search leer accessories economic metrics aeronca aircraft corp middletown oh author kevin a hassett adobe dreamweaver cs3 download rapidshare action man hasbro bacterial endocarditis prophylaxis fishingknotsguide.info dota org ua bob julie indianapolis alconeco.com short storys by kurt vonnegut jr jack cornwell chesterfield auction antique trademark keystone with r inside a funny thing happen $2 star note 1988 regal boats 1927 clarence morris ohio cincinatti atozfabrication.com animals kept in captivity free sheet music les miserables florida sda church fin amour cat safety collars edi rama anywhere map kara and hickory nc and softball angkor wat wallpaper distance los angles palo alto alpine valley rv campground vt clearwater enviro technologies ls-pics pthc terrence agnew remus harry ticklish beckett injected skimmer answer to foreclosure complaint in florida 1937 ford v8 flatback 212 degrees youtube gentlemens choice spire denver amalfi ristorante italiano calendrier vacances scolaires engineering resignation letter beautyrest incline memory foam matress pad california carlsbad biz seeker kansastowns.us hendrickson international adaptation and human evolution bankatlantic get around long wait times freemasons crescent city ca cosmik debris frank zappa guitar tabs correlation coefficent r adventure 16 carriage ridge resort at horseshoe valley kip buchanon chockfast red grout mic preamplifier tcs indian vaginas flex fuell pusher celebs fakes battle archipelago travel diffuser free shipping cocoa beach florida restraunts predictive maintenance jobs freemasons and the flinstones child labor in africa invisible children boise state bs bid bob becker demonstrations cestihandbag.com alice washburn hillsdale free will baptist college baseball snack aaa dare to prepare advair and copd dog groomers huntley il heritagevt.com buy phentermine 37.5 in tennessee histology of loose connective tissue air marley cole haan default ip address 3com 5500 ei coping with psoriasis foxconn dvd drive not visible adobe complete ebook publisher site web dna testing a fell pony dr thomas griggs nc catholicism wikipedia forschner victorinox fibrox knives 97 del sol front bumper bristol commons sunnyvale ca avp 2 webring kim b shay bleomycin administration duration wholesalegiftsdirect.com 7 grade history handouts musical tarzan stacie dyck airports southwest florida hyalgan.com karvonen thr formula margret benning fairview ohio maricopa community colleg augustas caesar brisket holiday jewish 29th company 165th depot brigade ball joint replacement expense coaching football running backs art deco abstract sculpture darren bignell heritage david eileen field avon motorcyle tires occ australia competition alternative treatment for esophageal cancer 77th field artillery reunion association bamum beaded throne any new developments in compounding pharmacies bethany templeton in rhode island 688 hunter killer manual heat transfer and thermodynamics alan wison sculpture epidural steriod injection for ruptured disc bmw x3 action title st augustine wasting cooking oil caterpillar host plant dill access export table to excel bank-fund staff fcu washington sla batteries acoustic energy aegis 1 constitution plaza hartford ct celebrities dumb down girls encouragement from the bible imommies.com